Casita Taqueria sold to new owners after 15 years in St. Pete

All three Casita Taqueria locations have been sold. Pictured is the Central Avenue location | Crow’s Nest

After 15 years of serving tacos, burritos, and other Mexican favorites in St. Pete, Casita Taqueria has changed hands. But its new owners say customers shouldn't expect any major changes.

Don and Gwen Arvin, who opened the first Casita Taqueria in St. Pete in 2011, recently sold the business to Michael and Brittney Fry. The husband-and-wife team moved to Florida from Cincinnati over the summer with their 9-year-old son, Davey.

The Arvins announced the sale in a social media post on Wednesday, reflecting on the business they spent the past 15 years building.

“Today, with mixed emotions and incredibly grateful hearts, we want to share that we have officially sold Casita Taqueria,” the Arvins wrote. “It’s bittersweet to walk away from something that has been such a meaningful part of our lives. In many ways, Casita has felt like an extension of our family, and saying goodbye is harder than we ever imagined.”

The sale includes all three Casita Taqueria locations in St. Pete, including the restaurant on Central Avenue in the Grand Central District, a second location on 4th Street North, and a third on 66th Street North in west St. Pete.

For longtime customers, little is expected to change. The Frys plan to maintain the existing menu, operating hours, and overall restaurant experience.

Casita Taqueria’s Pescado taco topped with homemade pineapple salsa, lime infused cabbage, and cilantro | Casita Taqueria

Casita will continue serving its selection of tacos, burritos, loaded bowls, salads, and tortas, along with sides such as chips, salsa, queso, and guacamole. The menu also includes beer, sangria, wine-based margaritas, and churros for dessert.

Michael Fry told St. Pete Rising that he and his wife had spent several years searching for the right business to purchase before discovering Casita Taqueria.

The couple had considered relocating to several Florida communities, including Destin and Anna Maria Island, before settling on St. Pete. They moved to the area in July.

“When we came down here and visited the stores, we just fell in love with the food and the staff,” Fry said in a conversation with St. Pete Rising. “It was just a unique business.”

Rather than purchase a restaurant that needed significant changes, the Frys were drawn to Casita's established operations, employees, and customer base.

Inside Casita Taqueria’s Central Avenue restaurant | Google

“The company has run successfully as a family-owned company for years,” Fry said. “They have a very loyal and hardworking staff there, and a loyal community following, and we don't want to do anything to disrupt that or change anything that would affect the business in a negative way.”

Both Michael and Brittney have previous experience in the restaurant industry.

Brittney worked as a server to help pay her college tuition, while Michael owned a bakery and coffee shop in the mid-2000s before becoming involved with several restaurant franchise concepts. He has also worked in real estate.

Although Michael has experience in franchising, he said the couple has no plans to franchise Casita Taqueria. However, additional company-owned locations could eventually be in the works.

“We want to continue the company as owner-operators and keep it a family business,” Fry said. “If there's any growth, it will probably come internally from us opening new stores in the future.”

Fry said the couple would like to expand throughout the Tampa Bay area, although their immediate priority is becoming familiar with the existing restaurants and their operations.

Casita Taqueria debuted in 2011 on 4th Street North | Casita Taqueria

Casita Taqueria's history dates back to October 2011, when Don and Gwen Arvin opened their first restaurant inside a small bungalow at 2706 4th Street North.

The couple drew inspiration from the independently owned Mexican restaurants they frequented while traveling along the West Coast. The restaurant's name, Casita, means "little house" in Spanish, a reference to its original home.

But in 2014, the Arvins were forced to relocate when their original restaurant was demolished to make way for Trader Joe's.

They found a new home at 2663 Central Avenue in the Grand Central District, converting a former Texaco gas station built in 1935 into a restaurant.

The business returned to 4th Street North in 2015, opening a second location at 2701 4th Street North, across the street from its original home.

The Arvins later expanded to west St. Pete, opening a third restaurant at 2991 66th Street North in the Tyrone area.

Now, the Frys are settling into their new roles as restaurant owners and looking forward to continuing the business the Arvins started.

“We're just so excited to be a part of the community,” Fry said. “We love the area. It's definitely a big move down here, but it's been wonderful.”